I struggle with the concept of forgiveness, but I think it belongs on this list. In part, because I think it is something Christians are called to do and in part because one of the goals of this site is to share dangerous ideas. And I think grace and forgiveness are two of the most dangerous ideas on the planet. But I struggle with the concept of forgiveness.
About 18 months ago, a friend of mine did something pretty horrible to my family and a church. The specifics don't really matter, but it was basically a severe betrayal of trust and relationship. All together, it was a pretty disgusting experience.
For a while, I would just get drunk on rage anytime I saw his name on my instant messenger list. I wanted to punch AOL in the face every time he logged on. As I mentioned, I am not awesome at forgiveness.
While in Charlotte for my grandmother’s birthday, I overheard my uncle telling my father about what it means to forgive. A few hours later I was able to ask him a couple of other questions on a topic I was clearly failing.
My uncle is a 6 foot 3, carved from stone, retired Air Force Colonel. He used to fly Air Force 2, the Vice President's plane, and has a long, decorated career behind him. He’s one of the most Godly men I’ve ever met and when he talks, rooms tend to go quiet. When I told him about the money that was stolen from me, he shared a story from his days in the Air Force.
During the Vietnam War, his friend got captured by the enemy. (The first time I shared this story, I thought it was North Koreans but I had the details mixed up.) While he was sitting in his cell, other American prisoners started to tap out an urgent message to him in Morse code. The faint sounds through the wall told him, “Don’t hate Raul. Don’t hate Raul.” Over and over again, these words were repeated. The message went on to say that Raul was a Cuban torture specialist that had been brought in to work over the prisoners. (That there is an international network of torture specialists is more than a little terrifying by the way.)
The message they were so frantic to give this new prisoner was that, yes, Raul was going to torture him, but that was only physical pain. That would end eventually, but it would be the seeds of hate for Raul that would threaten to eventually kill him. It would be his anger and rage against Raul that would eat him like a cancer, leaving him empty long after Raul had stopped the torture.
My uncle thinks holding a grudge is like carrying the offender’s dead body around with you. You have to let it go, or it just weighs on you and suffocates all the good things in your life.
I’d like to say I had a Eureka moment that night talking to my uncle and all my anger toward my former business partner instantly disappeared. It didn’t, but I did write him an email when I got home. I told him I choose to forgive you. You might never ask for it, but I choose to offer you forgiveness.
And the truth is, my friend is a good guy. He's funny and a blast to be with. He made a mistake. That is not who he is, that is something he did. What he did isn't that different from some of the horrible mistakes I've made in my own life. He needs forgiveness just like I do. He's a messed up human, just like me. And regardless, I am called to love him. But by initially refusing to forgive him, I was unable to see all of that.
Has every day been sunny since then? No, it would be fake of me to say it has. But now, when I see his name pop up on my instant messenger buddy list and I’m tempted to pick back up his 6′4″ dead body, I remember, “Don’t hate Raul. Don’t hate Raul.”
Oh my ...
ReplyDeleteI had it pretty rough growing up and held a lot of unforgiveness toward my parents. That turned into depression in my adulthood. So I know what you mean about forgiveness being hard. Finally one day it was so clear to me that I need to let it all go. So as I prayed about forgiving them, BAM!, it hit me like a ton of bricks. I had sinned, too, because I was holding on to unforgiveness I had to ask God to forgive me for not forgiving them. All that unforgiveness had damaged my relationship with God and sabotaged me ministering to my parents. When I prayed those prayers, for the first time in years, I felt free. When I went to my parents and asked them to forgive me for holding things against them you could almost hear the walls coming down between us. The past isn't gone but the raw edge of it is filed smooth. It's amazing what letting go will do.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the reminder that hating someone is like carrying the weight of them around with you forever......
ReplyDeleteI wonder if unforgiveness is one of the things Jesus talks about when he says,
"Are you tired? Worn out? Burned out on religion? Come to me. Get away with me and you'll recover your life. I'll show you how to take a real rest. Walk with me and work with me—watch how I do it. Learn the unforced rhythms of grace. I won't lay anything heavy or ill-fitting on you. Keep company with me and you'll learn to live freely and lightly."
I have to say, compared to forgiving an infamous torturer, my struggle to forgive that girl for winking at my hubby pales in comparison. Thanks for the reality check.
ReplyDeleteNot that I'm fully rejecting the idea of body slamming her against a pew if she ever does it again. But at least she's not holding hot pokers to my feet. Something to consider. Whew, this forgiveness thing is tough.
I thought this was going to be a post about Shaun Groves' trainer. :-P
ReplyDelete~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If the guy bugs you so much, why not just take him off your buddy list??
My dad left my mom and his 4 kids over 30 years ago. He left for another woman. She would be No. 2 of a total of 8 wives. There are many reasons he has been unable to maintain a healthly relationship, but my husband pointed out to me that it is my dad's inability to forgive himself for what he did to us that keeps him in constant bondage. I forgave my dad a long time ago and have been able to move forward. My sisters refuse to forgive him. They are stuck emotionally. When my dad remarried almost 2 years ago, they refused to go to the wedding. They have never met my dad's wife, and it really sucks having to make excuses to my kids as to why we have to celebrate birthdays and holidays with everyone separately. For my mom's part in all of this, she has stated on numerous occasions that she will never forgive my dad for what he did. The saddest part of this story is that everyone involved here claims to be Christians and attends church on a regular basis. Talk about missing the point! My kids are still pretty young, and I've asked the "mature adults" in this situation to leave my kids out of it, but the pink elephant in the room just keeps getting bigger. I've tried to encourage forgiveness, but apparently I was too young when my dad left to truly appreciate how horrible it really was. I am so grateful that Christ's forgiveness is not on a sliding scale.
ReplyDeleteJon you have no idea how much I needed this. I have been holding on to something that really bothers me and I think I may be the only one who is bothered by this. I just can't seem to let it go. I thought about writing this guy an email but I'm not sure how I will feel. I know I need to do something. Thanks for your words.
ReplyDeleteThe mental image of picking up someone else is powerful. I'm a pansy and don't want to keep picking up dead things. Thank you for this; I needed it this morning.
ReplyDeleteI have a good, long memory that is great for remembering random stories about Sunday School, but also really great for holding onto times of when someone has done me wrong. A few years ago, I sat down and made a list of everyone I needed to forgive. It was long. I then sat there, thinking and praying about each person/associated event. It has definitely helped. And when the old painful memories come bubbling up, at they are wont to do, I can also remember praying about it. That usually helps me move one.
ReplyDeleteThanks. I really needed to hear about Raul. Perfect timing.
ReplyDeleteWow, this was deep. I really want to meet your uncle. He sounds like a rock star.
ReplyDeleteI just recently renewed a friendship with someone--we had both hurt each other, but I was probably the instigator. I'm glad she chose to forgive me and I her. And we have been communicating back and forth over the past few weeks and it's as if we never lost touch. God is good.
It is so hard to forgive sometimes, but it's a lesson we all have to learn. (I'm still learning.)
ReplyDeleteAnd remember....that you become what you do not forgive! Great post!
ReplyDeleteAs someone who did a horrible terrible something to her family and friends let me add my thoughts. I recently did a horribly unspeakable thing to those I love most. In my pain/shame/guilt I wanted to throw myself in front of a car, jump off a building, down enough pills so that my heart would stop beating, etc. In spite of my sin the person I hurt THE most (aside from God) FORGAVE me and I cannot even put into words what that showed me about God and His love and how I am reminded daily of what it means to live in grace and I have also witnessed the freedom forgiving me has given those whom I have hurt.
ReplyDeleteBatman (Andy Stanley) once wrote a book that was originally titles “Like a Rock.” I can never remember the new title, because that is not the book I read. It is a book about Character. There is a brilliant chapter on forgiveness. He gives hi father credit for the concepts as I remember. He compares bitterness to a Trojan horse in our lives. He explains that our problem with forgiveness is we see it as a gift for the person who hurt us, but God gave us forgiveness as a gift for us to protect us from the cancer of bitterness. Pretty compatible with your Uncle’s story. Great post on a subject that is so important to us. We ignore that forgiveness is a decision separate from healing in the relationship.
ReplyDeletePete
Man ... this is an awesome post. Thanks for sharing it. I enjoy reading your blog - it makes me laugh, but this post touched me so deeply as this is something I always struggle with. I think "Don't hate Raul" might have to become a well-worn phrase around my house!
ReplyDeleteExcellent post...Just found your blog and it's great!!!
ReplyDeleteI ahve always thought that I was a bit odd in that I am forgiving to a fault of honest mistakes, but will hold a grudge forever for intentional ones. It's such a weird thing to have. One part of me is light and forgiveness, the other is black-hearted hatred. I guess that this area just happens to be the duality of me, because I am relatively balanced in most other aspects...
ReplyDeleteWow, I've never commented here before but I'm so moved today. I'm personally dealing with this issue - right now! God is leading me to learn to forgive and I just don't understand how to do it. (I feel learning impaired) I've been reading you for a couple of months and have seriously enjoyed the posts but BAM! Then you post about me (and it seems like a lot of others). It's just so amazing the way God works in our lives. I feel blessed everytime. Now if I could just get with the program. Got any more good tips?
ReplyDeletelovin your blog bro. I'm totally copping the story of your uncle's for a sermon illustration this weekend. i only teach once or twice a year, and this week i'm covering the Lord's prayer and this story makes the point of forgiving as we are forgiven nicely. of course i'll look like a total loser when i credit you as "this guy on the internet who told this story..." but i believe you
ReplyDeleteGod is good
jpu
umbl0g.blogspot.com
Yes, forgiveness can be a difficult thing. A friend recently shared another example: Resentment/unforgiveness is liking drinking poison hoping it will kill the other person. That's insane and it only hurts us. They're not even aware of how we are feeling.
ReplyDeleteAnd I've also thought a lot lately about Jesus telling the parable of the servant who was forgiven a massive debt, then had his fellow servant thrown in prison for not repaying a small debt. Jesus died for our sins--all of them--massive amounts of them. How tough should it be for us to forgive one (or even several) sin(s) committed against us? This is something I have to remind myself of everytime I'm tempted to hold a resentment.
Thank you Jon. There are some people including myself that I need to forgive. While I'm not there yet, your blog helps me.
ReplyDelete"Don't Hate Raul" belongs in the dictionary.
ReplyDeleteAnother thing about forgiveness is to remember that it is a process. It isn't a quick, I forgive you and move on. That's not forgiveness; that's avoidance or pretending that you didn't get hurt. Forgiveness begins with saying, "I have a right to demand justice, but I am dropping the charges."
But, that is only the start. Healing of the injury and the relationship takes time, just like ever other way God changes us. When you forgive someone, you are making a commitment to the process of being reconciled with the one who injured you, for however long it takes.
Great post! I know in my own life, when I have struggled to forgive someone, God reminds me of just how much forgiveness, grace & mercy He has given me--and continues to give me. Even when I didn't (or don't) "deserve it". Jesus died for me KNOWING all the terrible things I would do/say/think. Even knowing the paths I would chose in my BC days. Yet, He loved me and gave Himself for me... *sigh* makes me love Him all the more!
ReplyDeleteHi Jon, you are a wonderful writer, and I enjoy your blog very much. I wanted to encourage you that it is normal to feel anger, and your hurt and anger do need to be felt and dealt with in healthy ways, and that that is not the same thing as unforgiveness. It is good to set new boundaries with someone who has violated your trust. It's okay to not want to be his best buddy right now. That is not the same thing as unforgiveness. Just be careful what you do with your feelings, don't use them as an excuse to seek revenge, etc. Sometimes writing a strongly worded letter that you never send helps. I've done that before when I was really mad at someone, and I wrote it all in red pen, I was so mad, and I cried my way through the letter, and I didn't stop writing until I was done, and do you know, after that, I really was done. I ripped the whole thing up, and i haven't had an issue with the thing, or the people involved, since. I hope that helps.
ReplyDeleteMichelle in California
thanks for this post. I was recently hurt by a friend I loved, and still love very much and I've been spending a lot of time thinking about forgiveness. There was a point where I felt like I hadn't let go, and I did a bit of searching. R.T.Kendall says something interesting about the situation I found myself in, after forgiveness - forgiveness doesn't mean that there aren't consequences. I found out something about the person I cared for that completely changed the way I relate to them. I felt better for a while, but sometimes I still also am tempted to get my rage on just by seeing their name! The question I would like to ask everyone here is - what do you do when the person who hurt you refuses to acknowledge that they hurt you - so technically, they don't ASK for forgiveness - they just don't believe they hurt you (?!). I think it's one thing to let go of a dead weight, and another thing to have to have it following you everyday, doing the same things it did to hurt you before, and expecting nothing to change. Just a weird situation I've experienced recently .
ReplyDeleteThanks for your permission to use the Raul the torturer story. I did and gave the name of your blog and you, about minute 26 at
ReplyDeletehttp://www.revelation320.org/my_weblog/2008/07/matthew-6.html
God is good
jpu
The biggest issue that I have with forgiveness is not the limit of forgivness but the idiocy of repeating the same behavior under the 7*70 theory. I don't have to forgive 7*70 because once I see that a particular person is toxic (especially self righteous ones) I avoid them like SARS. I lost a business due to the actions of a member of my church so I will never again engage him in business transactions again. Ripped off once = forgiven once. However the future need to forgive is dramatically reduced because I won't get into that situation. We no longer loan money to church people. If we have extra we GIVE it so we don't have to worry about getting it back. Thus we have to forgive far less often than if we repeated the behavior. It's like the people who forgive someone who molested them as a child. Forgiveness is one thing restoration of the relationship is a whole different thing.
ReplyDeleteNot everyone is worth having around and there are dirtbags even in the church. A little common sense goes a long way. Sure hating Raul was not the way to go but I seriously doubt that anyone was having him over for a barbecue.
Thanks, again, for being so honest.
ReplyDelete