Pages

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

#604. The Arch Rival Family at Church

Dear Arch Rival Family at Church,

How did you do it?

Will you tell me your secrets now that we're grown up and we're not attending the same church? How were you able to be exactly like my family, only better? Did you know I considered you our arch rival family? Did you know that when we sat around the table for dinner your family was held up as the pinnacle of Christian servitude and discipline and awesomeness of all varieties?

I bet you didn't. You were probably too busy helping orphan baby barn owls to notice my jealous glares. You were probably too busy donating your spare kidneys to strangers to know that secretly, the seventh grade version of me kept looking for some sign that you were a robot. Nobody could be that perfect!

But you were. When I was lazy and tried to pass a rainy Saturday afternoon in front of the television, my mom would say, "You know the arch rival kids are doing yard work for a crippled woman that lives in their neighborhood right now. In the rain. With their bare hands."

And then I'd get up, go outside and kick a rake in the face out of frustration because somewhere across town you were winning. If I volunteered for something at church you had already volunteered for ten somethings. If I memorized one Bible verse you memorized the book of Philippians.

Was it Diet Rockstar? The can says it contains milk thistle, which I think is what Eeyore from Winnie the Pooh ate all the time which is confusing because he was so mellow, but it does promise to "provide an incredible energy boost for those whoe lead active and exhausting lifestyles - from athletes to rockstars." Is that it? Were you hopped up on energy drinks, barely controlling the leg jitters from all the guarana coursing through you at all times? You can tell me. Unless the answer is "the fruit of the spirit." Please don't say that. I'll definitely sin in my heart and probably my punching hand if that's your response to my question of “what were you on?”

We've moved on haven't we? I go to a church that’s too big for me to really develop a good Arch Rival Family, that curious family who seems to be the holier, more put together, more perfect version of your own. They're never late to Sunday School. Their kids never have those kind of bruises and scrapes that make it look like you're allowing them to play with bear cubs and jig saw blades at home. They never accidentally run out of regular yogurt for a casserole recipe and instead use vanilla yogurt which makes your chicken dish taste like a dessert and a main course got into a cat fight in which both parties lost.

So what was your secret? Mine was that I was really insecure and judgmental at the time, so even though you weren't purposefully doing anything to attack my family, I definitely considered you a nemesis. Or a competitor in some weird church game. The whole thing makes no sense. Sorry about that.

But how about you? How did you do all those things you managed to do? It was Diet Rockstar, wasn't it?

You can tell me.

Sincerely,

Jon

41 comments:

  1. I had one of those! Well, mainly it was an arch rival girl, but her family was pretty darn perfect, too. She was blonde and smiley and wore those expensive Easter dresses that came with a matching bonnet and her mom was always making cookies for Wednesday nights. Oh, and she got tons of solos in the Junior Choir and was on the Bible Quiz team....

    I think I should stop now!

    ReplyDelete
  2. They didn't have Diet Rockstar when I was growing up. But they did have black beauties. And mothers little helper when you actually wanted to sleep. Of course, now they run a recovery ministry. A very successful recovery ministry.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This reminds me a McGee and Me episode, "Back to the drawing board." An artist could draw a better than Nick. Anybody remember that show?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I attend a christian school and it seems that at times their is even arch rival christian student. The one who always has all the work done with handwriting that could be the next great font. He/She wrote 4 pages for the bible homework, which only required 2 paragraphs. They somehow seem to miraculously appear throughout the school helping various kids with classwork and the little first grader who got lost in the high school corner of the school. A weakness though? Maybe they are just too perfect.

    ReplyDelete
  5. What do you have against Ned, Rod, and Todd (and for a while, Maude)?

    @Nicodemus at Nite: I remember it really well. That video was the one in which McGee had his own metal robot rival. The real question is, do you remember the three (were there more?) "newer" videos that were made later, after the Christmas video? One was about Nick trying to be "cool" (hehe) and another was about when Nick's Romanian pen pal came for Thanksgiving.

    ReplyDelete
  6. dear jon,

    i respect your honesty and i will tell you my secret: i have based my familial existence on God's favorite creature, the mid western prairie dog. though you'll no doubt be relieved to know that i noticed your taunting glares, I see we are still at odds. while you are championing the prideful, soaring eagle during worship services (which preys on god's favorite creature), i am busying doing object lessons on perseverance, humility, and eschatology with the prarie dogs.

    Might i suggest a more humble animal than your worship eagle... remember: satan has talons too.

    in the Lord's tender love,

    Your Familial Nemisis

    ReplyDelete
  7. Our secret? We're really Mormon. You should have known based on how often we rode bikes around town.

    ReplyDelete
  8. wow. that was hilarious because i thought the same things growing up. i liked how you wrote that it was because of insecurity and judgments--we all get like that at times. but thank God that He loves us just the same!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Paul, that cracked me up!!!

    Nicodemus, Yup! Remember it, owned it, and referenced it the other day to blank stares...

    Jon, My secret was equal parts perfectionism, legalism and not wanting to disappoint anyone...turns out that God isn't too impressed with those things.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Dude... this was fantastic. Go hard brother

    ReplyDelete
  11. Her name was Sarah. And her family was "perfect."

    My mom even said once to me that I should be "more like Sarah."


    As for Mcgee and Me, my favorite episode was The not so great escape. That cheesy early 90's song that plays after he gets out of the revenge of the blood suckers is burned into my memory forever.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "worship prairie dog". No, sorry, doesn't have that reach out and grab you to it.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I don't have a family--I have an archrival wife! I don't even think about her until I get to church and I see her skinny little body and perfect EVERYTHING on stage singing and always smiling. We have kids similar ages, and I have no idea how she looks so put-together all the time. She's perfect and I'm so jealous! She also is always smiling and worshipping, when that doesn't come as easily for me.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Yes, there was an "arch rival family" as I was growing up, even though our church was very small.

    A few years ago, I realized that comparing ourselves to others leads to only two things: either pride that we are better than some people or jealousy that they are better than us. Thanks for the reminder.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Yeah i can relate but the family contained my best friend and i actually just wanted to be a part of their family and wasn't jealous as such, more respectful. I spent a lot of time at their house so i know that it was authentic (although i did gloss over a few things in my mind, looking back). Nevertheless it inspired me

    It did annoy me though when my parents would try to motivate me by comparing me to this girl. I was like i'm a totally different person and i'll never be that good anyway!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think maybe you need to do a post on the flip-side of this family. Every church has a family which every other member of the congregation is glad they are not related because of criminal tendencies/substance abuse/physical abuse/multiple marriages/teenage pregnancies. To be blunt, the rest of the congregation looks down on these people because they make the rest of us feel a little more "holy".

    ReplyDelete
  17. Either I was oblivious to this kind of thing growing up or my family was the arch rival family at church... at least up until my parents divorced.
    What is it with our human obsession to compare ourselves with others?

    ReplyDelete
  18. OH dear-that was my family growing up. I didnt find out until college that a fair amt of my friend's parents compared their family to ours. Ugh. Our family I always thought was just normal-no dark secrets, no split personalities depending on the situation, just very genuine parents. In fact, no one at church seemed to care that my family was one of the only public school families who also sent their kids to secular universities.

    But, there was also a decent amount of Christian brainwashing in the form of McGee and Me movies, Buttercream Gang movies (anyone else watch these-they are actually Mormon), and the Mandy books.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I was always kinda hoping they'd adopt me. :)

    ReplyDelete
  20. Interesting - I think we were the family - by all outward appearances it was perfect. When one of the family actually "failed" at something many in the church rejoiced - very Christian attitude - you think?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Beth is right.

    It was the perfectionism and the crippling fear of failure! But don;t forget the deep secret feeling of being left out of all the "fun" the sinner kids were having.

    ReplyDelete
  22. This was great. It's absolutely what I am thinking about today. We need to quit wanting to be someone else (or someone else's family) and be happy with what God created us to be.

    WV:cookswe- My baby girl asking for a cookie.

    ReplyDelete
  23. HAHA my husband's family had one of these arch rival families at their church. It was the family of another pastor. We saw them just this past week when we visited, it is so funny to watch the dynamics!

    ReplyDelete
  24. I can't really relate, but I enjoyed the post.

    ReplyDelete
  25. ah yes...
    I have nightmares because of this family. I couldn't tell you how many times I heard the mom say, "Character is who you are when no one is around." Over and over she would say that while sporting coolots (baggy capris).

    It's all cool though she ended up sleeping with a trustee who was also her daughters father in law.

    Thank God I go to a different church now but I'm gonna comment anonymously anyways.

    ReplyDelete
  26. @Nicodemus at Nite: I think I wrote that McGee & Me episode... (it was a long time ago... )....

    ReplyDelete
  27. We were on-and-off-again Unitarians. My mother never held up other religious families to us unless she talked about "those Holier-than-thou" people!

    ReplyDelete
  28. I am amused to find out how many other SCL readers were the 'Arch Rival family' and know 'McGee and Me'. I'm not gonna lie, I occasionally sport the McGee hairdo when I roll out of bed in the morning... it always makes me chuckle.

    JenR-I definitely read the Mandy books too (hadn't thought of them in years, but your comment brought it all back).

    ReplyDelete
  29. Oh totally. In fact, living in the OC one has myriad opportunities to put any number of people in the 'perfect arch rival' category. I have to focus fairly diligently on just what God wants from me, or I start seeing the other Mom's and other families as perfect. You know, I know they don't yell at their kids or feed them cereal for breakfast AND dinner some days. Gosh... I'm tired now. I'm going to go have more coffee. You know, the elixir of spirituality!

    ReplyDelete
  30. Jon,

    How about the family who was the "horrible warning" to all other families.....

    ReplyDelete
  31. Whenever something odd happened at our house growing up - say, Mom slid aside the shower curtain and found basketballs in the bathtub or Dad had taken over the living room with fishing tackle - Mom would sign in despair and say, "I bet this never happens at the _________." (Fill in Arch Rival family name.)

    ReplyDelete
  32. This is absolutely hilarious. (My cousins informed us, growing up, we that we were their arch rivals...we laughed...if only they knew!)

    ReplyDelete
  33. Isn't it sad that we have this pettiness in church?

    ReplyDelete
  34. Yeah, let's tear down those "Arch Rival Families" for daring to be anything better than average. How insensitive. They really should try to sin some more. Then we'd all feel better about ourselves.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Oh boy did I get this post! The thing is that nobody is perfect and bad stuff happens to us all. So any family that oozes the perpetual impression of perfection is just not being real. And that's sad. Your church family should be the safest place in the world to be yourself and share your struggles. It's hard not to resent them sometimes, but they don't need my judgement, they need love and encouragement, maybe more than us normal people :0)

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hey, Traveling Joe, prairie dogs eat their young. At least eagles prey on other species.

    Some "arch rival families" are actually staged by the mom or dad or both and eventually crumble under the pressure.

    A family at our church was always doing holy things. If you didn't notice, they would tell you-- adopting another child, living without some worldy pleasure, etc.

    The mom was always telling us to submit to our husbands, and how perfect their marriage was. The dad was fond of telling everyone what God had told him-- usually something we were doing wrong or something we could do for him.

    They were always moving and changing churches-- each church choice was a direct word from God. I suspected that they just wanted a new audience to impress with their super-holiness, then I felt guilty for my pride and jealousy toward this super-fam.

    This summer they declared bankruptcy and she left him. The kids they adopted to provide them with a stable home are now forced to choose a parent and bounce back and forth. I guess they are arch rivals with each other now.

    ReplyDelete
  37. that sounds like a parenting issue... may i never compare my kids to kids in other families, because the family they have is different than any other family... therefore having different experiences and opportunities to "perform perfect christianity"... i'm going to send my mom an email thanking her for not doing this to me, trusting my dad already knows because he left for heaven a year and a half ago...

    thanks for this reminder. its kind of like reading the joseph/jacob story and being reminded not to create sibling rivalry

    ReplyDelete
  38. I married into the Arch Rival family because I wanted to be a super Christian, JUST LIKE THEM.

    About three years after the wedding, I found out that the Super Deacon Dad had been sexually molesting the Super Oldest Girl for quite some time.

    And things went downhill from there.

    I'm divorced now. They still look pretty perfect, but some people know the truth. I learned a lot about myself along the way.

    ReplyDelete
  39. My church has "Christian Barbie and Ken". I thought it was just my family who called them that, but I was wrong.
    They are incredibly cute, lead worship, Sunday school. He fills in for the minister when she goes on vacation. They are "mergers" along with her brother and sister. A term to describe the incredibly high percentage of couples who marry from the college (state not Christian) that we all attended. When a homeless person interupted them on the way to a wedding reception, they didn't say "sorry no cash" they gave him some after they held his hand and prayed for him. One fellow member said she did well with sermon against envy until the closing song when she watched Barbie struggle to keep her pants from falling off her size 6 hips. (Women understand this. Amen?) And just in the past year, they adopted a baby from China after taking their kids to an SCC concert. Oh and what gets my Mom is how Ken and his brother in law are always sitting with & hugging the in-laws during church.
    Wow, it takes a lot of words to describe them.

    ReplyDelete
  40. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete