Pages

Monday, June 30, 2008

#321. The background music for prayers.

Sometimes, when the whisper of importance is just not cutting it, your minister will have a little music play in the background while the prayer is said. Usually, it's just some soft piano designed to sweep you away to prayerville. It's almost as if the music is saying "Time to get serious, please slow down, close your eyes now, don't look around, it's prayyyyyeerrrr time." As you can imagine, this whole experience raised a few questions for me. Questions that I felt, were best expressed in numerical fashion:

1. What if you did that with other moments in your life?
Can you imagine how awesome it would be if you could keep a little tape player in your pocket that you played during other situations in your day? Seriously, what if you were giving a presentation at work and all the sudden you put your hand in your pocket and pressed play? Suddenly the dulcitone notes of an "everyone listen up" song would float out of your pants. Or if you sensed you were about to get dumped you could play some emo music from your jeans. That would be fantastic.

2. Have you ever written your own lyrics for that music?
I have. When it comes on, I usually start singing to myself, "This is the music I play, when it's time to pray, I like to break it down nice, and put the moment on iccceeee." Or I sing along to the Counting Crows "Round Here" melody and say something like, "Round here, we always pray with a song, round here, we always pray too long, round here we think the piano hides our words in a musical sweater, as if that makes it better, could that minister's shirt get any wetter?"

3. Who writes this music?
Is there a group of like four people that write all that music? Certainly some of it is ad libbed by the musicians on stage, but are there places that sell music by prayer length? Can you buy a "five minute prayer song with three serious moments and one light moment at the end?" Do other musicians call the prayer songwriters sell outs?

4. Are the drums banned from this?
I sometimes hear the little chimes stroked during the prayer song but no one ever lets the drums sit in on this. Are they banned? Are they like the Rudolph the red nosed reindeer of instruments, sent to live on an island of misfits with the prayer triangle and the prayer maracas?

5. Who discovered this?
I am going to guess Moses invented this, but only because I always guess Moses. Yesterday I wrote about Noah's ark and even included him in that. I guess I'm a big Moseite. What can I say?

I love the prayer song and have to warn you. I might be speaking at a college this summer. If I do, please know that I am going to without a doubt be rocking the pocket prayer music.

49 comments:

  1. I am the guy that plays this. We have a code that forbids us from talking, but I'm like that magician that gives away all the secrets on TV, here are your answers:

    1. I do.
    2. Stop it. You're ruining my moment.
    3. Me. It's 100% improv. I consider myself the miles davis of finger-picking.
    4. There was actually a falling out between drummers and prayer music. They used to be allowed to play (just cymbals, no drums) but because of some... complications, it's better if they just stay in their seat.
    5. Correct, it was moses!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I've been asked to do this stuff from time to time as a church pianist. Mostly, I just improvise but throw in a few recognizable melodies for good measure. Don't want to do that too much, though, as people start trying to mentally play Name That Tune while the prayer is going on. Don't want to take away the whole purpose of the prayer music, you know.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i'm the piano version of Mike. i pride myself on my beautiful piano improv, as well as incorporating chord progressions from completely inappropriate songs (last week was Piano Man) and having no one notice but the worship leader and myself. It's the way we church musicians "keep it real".

    We have to have our fun. There are only 4 chords in "Here i am to worship." Chris Tomlin is the Green Day of church music. Easy and fun for listening, but is bringing down the musical iq's of church goers everywhere.

    i really like the idea of the "prayer sweater". That is totally what it is! i call it "musical manipulation": bringing emotions and feelings into a prayer so people feel like especially holy afterwards. :)

    But in the meantime, being a church musician is the best thing that's ever happened to me, and i'm getting paid to do my dream job.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have to say that I'm not a big fan of the music during prayer, it just seems a little to "I'm trying to control your mood right now and put you into a trance that will make you feel extra spiritual". My biggest pet peeve is when the acoustic guitar player thinks he or she can tune their guitar quick and no one will hear. We can hear you! Also, most of us won't know the difference if you're a fraction out of tune. But maybe I'm jealous and wish I new more than the chords G D A and E.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think the "background music for prayers" my be my biggest pet peeve in churches. Can't I just sit in silence and listen to God?!? (Just personal preference. No offense to pastors and worship leaders who have it...)

    ReplyDelete
  6. One time we were praying just before an urban life (cell group) meeting, the leader put on some music from his iPod. Turns out it was set to 'shuffle' so after the first song (standard prayer music) played through we suddenly found ourselves praying with Kelly Clarkson in the background...

    ReplyDelete
  7. Here's two sites that cash in on this. Yes - there are peopleactually making money at this!

    http://www.worshipflow.com/
    http://www.worshipscores.com/

    Note - I am in no way affiliated with either site. I 100% improvise my prayer underscores. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  8. My favorite is when the pastor finishes praying and starts talking quietly, maybe between-prayer talking, and the worship player stops and he turns around and says, "no, man, that was good. keep that going." and then he turns back to you like nothing ever happened. It makes me feel like I'm on The Office.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I read your blog from time to time and this one made me laugh out loud. not the token LOL that everyone writes in e-mails...but the real laugh out loud until you get little tears in the sides of your eyes...humor for Jesus - who would have thought...

    I too am the girl that plays this, so this hits close to home. I really did not think that people even noticed, but obviously they do...

    one other comment...
    the soundtrack that you play in your pocket is called an ipod...a lot of people have them.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I guess for me background music is about honoring God with His favorite major triads, not thinking about your next witty post.

    Now where's my medal?

    ReplyDelete
  11. In our services we have a "prayer ministry" time where people come forward for prayer with the pastor or with "prayer partners". We usually sing one verse and chorus of the song we're going to sing during the prayer time and then the pastor "sets up" the prayer time. Our pianist (pastor's wife) generally plays through the song while the pastor is "setting up" and I love to listen to her try to "time" the music just right so that right as the pastor finishes the "setup" we start singing the verse again. She's a prayer music ninja!

    ReplyDelete
  12. When the pastor looks at me for some prayer music, I quietly and ever so reverently start beatboxing Ice Ice Baby.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I always wondered if the person playing the prayer music thought they were too holy to pray or something. Then I realized that it is possible to play a four-chord progression over and over and still have brain cells left for prayer at the same time.

    But to be honest, I'm really not a fan. It does seem kind of manipulative in a way. Silence works great for me.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I completely agree with 6th-post Sarah.

    ReplyDelete
  15. pocket prayer music = next inclusion in the SCL dictionary.

    ps: sarah noting this as her greatest pet peeve, asking if she can just sit in silence and listen to God, made me think of another entry you could include for SCL, and that is: pastors telling us they're going to give us a few moments of silence before the service begins or before we move on to the next thing in order to talk to God, but then they use the entire time of silence to talk to us, telling us how to pray or what to focus on or even saying their own prayer for the whole congregation and the service out loud. i'm always so stoked to be told we're getting some silent time to center our thoughts on God and bring our hearts before him, so then i'm always slowly disappointed when i realize it's not going to actually happen when it's offered. are those pastors just afraid of the silence? i'd rather they be teaching us by example that silence is a gift, not something to be afraid of, especially when it comes to worshipping God in prayer.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yeah, as the chuch piano player I have to say I hate the drummer that pops up to join the prayer music.
    Imagine me wrapping your little prayer up in my pretty sweater all knitted with love - and here the drummer comes along and glues some leather to my yarn.
    NO.
    It is none good. none.

    Unfortunately though, as a musician I fully agree with all the people that hate prayer music. I want quiet when I pray - I can't concentrate when music is playing (unless I'm the one playing it). :)

    Not fair is it. :)

    ReplyDelete
  17. prayer maracas? Can i play them?

    ReplyDelete
  18. in my time as a criminal defense lawyer, i wanted a pianist or guitarist to be on hand to play at the crucial moment of my closing argument. just when i'm making what i believe to be the most compelling argument for a finding of not guilty, that chord would crescendo. it's a perfect transition into the working world. guess you could say that my heart and mind wasn't completely on God during those moments.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Yes, you can actually buy short little piano pieces specifically designed for situations like this. But we mostly just make it up on the spot. At Willow Creek in the 80s, I had to do this all the time, but was told not to use any recognizable tunes since they would distract people from their prayers.

    I have a keyboardist friend who finally wrote a piece called "Ever So Softly," because every week, the preacher would say, "Now, while the piano plays ever so softly, let us pray..."

    ReplyDelete
  20. So, do you have friends who help lead worship that gang up on you at all?

    However, I laugh because it's true.

    ReplyDelete
  21. My dad does large group children's ministry and has for years. These days there's no background music for prayers, but "back in the day" he always had "prayer music". It was a specific tape with an instrumental song called, maybe, "what kind of music does a rainbow make" or something like that. We just called it the "prayer music". I could recognize the tune within about 3 notes.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Oh man, please re-read this post to yourself in the voice of Bob Ross. Perhaps include a few happy trees, and you will be in sheer bliss. Seriously I automatically started reading it in his voice somehow......and it was hilarious! Try it. Don't just take my word for it. Test out that orange 'fro.

    ReplyDelete
  23. "Time to get serious, please slow down, close your eyes now, don't look around, it's prayyyyyeerrrr time."
    The preceding can only be done with Barry White's voice. "Oh yyyyyeeeaaaahhhhh."

    The other day, a bunch of my friends were sitting around and one said he was going to tell a sad story, so out came my guitar and the minor chords. It was pretty hilarious. Point being- I do this not just in church.

    I am sort of a prayer music aficionado. I can always pick out the tune. At my church back home, the organist plays the music, and it's always the song we just sang slowed wayyyyy down. Sometimes it's frustrating. "I......... could............. sing............ of ......your.... loooooooooove... foreverrrrrrr."
    Seriously. I want to pull my hair out.

    I think they should have a church soundtrack. Quiet stuff for prayers. Happy butterfly music when the pastor is talking about Heaven. Scary movie music when he's yelling at us about the "Fahrs of Heyl!"

    P.S. I did grow up in a very conservative environment where prayer time in church was "everyone except the pianist shut up" time. However, now that I live in Africa, I have a very different environment. One church I attend sometimes has prayers where everyone is praying at once. Aloud. And while it seems chaotic at first, it's quite beautiful. I've grown to enjoy it as a very spirit-filled experience. We're all praising God together! They do have more organized prayer time too- where one person prays and if you want to pray along, you do it quietly.
    Anyway, the moral of that story is: corporate prayer can be a very edifying thing. However, when I led worship at this church, I knew this would happen so I had to ask someone, "When they're all praying at once, how do you make it stop?"

    ReplyDelete
  24. I don't own proper mallets so I can either tinkle the bells on the cymbals with my nylon tips in an oh-so-ethereal manner, or kick the bass drum for a more intense "Jesus is coming to getcha" vibe.

    But usually I use the time to mentally rehearse my sweet lixx in the upcoming songs.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I actually like the prayer music.
    I admit that sometimes it's distracting but I know when I first began to voluntarily attend church (for a reason other than to socialize) I didn't really feel comfortable praying. Music helped to calm me down. It gave me something to focus on other than the folks around me. (Does anyone else get disttracted by the prayers of others during group prayer? I wonder if God feels slighted if I pause my prayer to amen someone else's prayer? Is that considered ear hustling?)

    ReplyDelete
  26. I never knew that this blog existed, I thought about starting one for Atheists, what do you think of the blog.

    Stuff God Hates? I look forward to coming on here and posting.

    http://stuffgirkslike.wordpress.com

    ReplyDelete
  27. jessica @pianomomsicle said: Chris Tomlin is the Green Day of church music.

    I LOVE that! That amuses me no end for some reason! :D

    ReplyDelete
  28. It's also a good indication that the sermon is over and lunch will be served soon.

    ReplyDelete
  29. "What if you did that with other moments in your life?"

    Oh yeah, it's confession time...

    I literally see my life as 37 years of music montages. And each time a great song comes out, I reflect back over a scene from my life and relive it with the music. It's so cool. I also picture being in Heaven one day as God and I go over my life in a scenario like some sort of really long powerpoint presentation set to music appropriate to the event we're watching.

    I probably lost friends who read this blog due to that confession. They didn't know how weird I was until just now. What time is that ugly people service??

    ReplyDelete
  30. Background music is verbal soft focus... It makes everything coming out of your mouth sound just a little extra special. Try saying something normal while somebody softly picks "At the Cross" behind you... CAN'T DO IT... It just comes out all "Come to Jesus."

    (I had teenage guitarists who would randomly play it just to mess with my head.)

    ReplyDelete
  31. The thing is at my church, my pastor is really unpredictable when it comes to wrapping up a service.

    So when I come up at the end back to the keyboard, I always start with what would be standard "prayer music" -- a few piano chords, layered in soft pads or strings, usually connected to whatever last slow worship song we'd sang before, or something else that God may have planted into my head that ties into whatever the pastor was talking about.

    But then sometimes he would switch it up on me... he would start all solemn and heart-stringy... but then by the end, he might get a little fiery, or he might just get kinda mellow and fun. He's got a tremendous amount of range, really.

    So I have to be ready. He might give the altar call, and nobody comes up, or just one or two people come up, so it's time to give the benediction and switch into the happy church-is-over music. And so I might break out a little Clavinova and play a few licks. One time I really wanted to break out into the intro of "Superstition" by Stevie Wonder, but I knew that might become a distraction.

    (Although once during a baby dedication, I did break out "Isn't She Lovely" and it was PERFECT. That was like my prayer music highlight of the month. Even the pastor smiled and started singing along.)

    ReplyDelete
  32. I always thought it was like the Academy Awards where they wanted the person to stop giving their "thank you" speech. Funny stuff.

    I'm pretty okay with prayer music, but I found it especially distracting one time when the pianist started playing "Winter Wonderland." I probably would have noticed "Piano Man," too. Sorry.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I forwarded this to our staff and worship band. Our main keyboard guy responded that he's used the chord progression from Van Halen's Jump before.

    Personally, I'm with some of the others who find it distracting no matter how subtle it is. I'm always trying to figure out what song they're playing.

    ReplyDelete
  34. "it just seems a little too "I'm trying to control your mood right now and put you into a trance that will make you feel extra spiritual"."

    Precisely. Go through a few sessions with a good hypnotherapist, and you'll quickly come to understand how worship services are planned.

    "One time I really wanted to break out into the intro of "Superstition" by Stevie Wonder, but I knew that might become a distraction."

    Besides, "when you believe in things you don't understand, then you suffer" isn't exactly the kind of thought you want to encourage during prayer.

    (aside to Jon: could you fix the software to allow blockquote tags? that'd help keep things clear.)

    ReplyDelete
  35. Makes you wonder - did some heavenly choir with oo's and ah's or some light harp sound kick in when Jesus started the sermon on the mount? Do people with ADD all of a sudden know to bow their heads and close their eyes when the music kicks in? It does help set the mood, but does a mood need to be set for prayer? Is the purpose to drown out people blowing their nose or coughing, kids making fart noises when they're not supposed to? Or is it to manipulate us to feel spiritual? Who cares if it sounds good, right? I think it all comes from the birth of movie soundtracks. And that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

    ReplyDelete
  36. I once was part of a small church where we had a really talented organist/pianist who could play anything by ear. Every so often, just to see if he could get away with it, he would work in a little "Do You Know the Muffin Man" on the organ during prayer time. As far as I knew, people still drew near the throne. I guess it's all in what you want to hear.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Love it! I might be on here all night just reading your blogs!

    Tricia Knapp
    Tobyhanna, PA

    ReplyDelete
  38. Okay. I actually am the one that plays this music at my church (yup, I'm the worship leader). Here are some things you should know:

    Yes, I'm trying to control and manipulate you. It's true.

    1. I have often wished my keyboard was small enough to fit into my pocket just for those other moments in my life.

    2. I am now writing the music to back up your first set of lyrics, but I'm quite certain that come Sunday my improv will sound a LOT like round here and I'm pretty sure I'll have a dumb smirk on my face while I sing your second set of lyrics in my head! Thanks a lot.

    3. I make it all up, and occasionally I'll borrow chord progressions from two or three different songs and string them together just to mess with those in the congregation who are trying to figure what song I'm playing instead of praying.

    4. If my drummer ever joined in the prayer music, I would have to stop the entire service just to reprimand him because it is a very serious infraction in church circles for the drummer to play during this holy time.

    5. It was totally Moses. It was right after he yelled at Aaron for screwing up while he was up on the mountain with God. Before he began praying over the group, he knew that a little prayer music was in order to make the Israelites realize the seriousness of the situation.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I'm pretty sure Prayerville is capitalized, Jon.

    ReplyDelete
  40. My drummer got so bored while we were doing prayer/communion instrumental, that he pulled out a bottle of chapstick to brush on his lips, and realizing he actually DID need to do a little cymbal thing on the downbeat, but w/ no stick in his hands, he proceeded to play with the chapstick tube instead. Yes, that's right. Prayertime drumming with chapstick tubes instead of drumsticks. Long live the lips.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I HAAAAAATE background music during prayer! It's virtually impossible for me to focus on praying if there's a song I know playing in the background.

    ReplyDelete
  42. My friends once played Weezer's "Say it Ain't So" during communion. That got so many comments on how beautiful it was.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Yep...that's me. The girl at the piano carrying out the orders of my pastor to create an emotional mood of god-closeness while he leads the congregation in a heart touching prayer.So I stand there at my keyboard for what seems like an eternity and make up stuff, playing whatever I feel like until I he says amen. What's even better is when I forget, or simply don't really feel like it. Then I get constantly reminded that our pastor wants me in the background. It's like the movie office space, they look at me and say "didn't you get the memo?". And yes, drums are only to use symbols, and maybe a guitarist can jump in with some picking. One day I'm going to bust out with Eye of the Tiger, or Numb by Linkin Park...that would be magnificent.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Noodling. This magnificent prayer music is called noodling. My mother is the MASTER of noodling. My pastor usually asks her to noodle, quite frequently! I will have to ask her if she has read this hilarious post. Her blog is- www.graceeveryday.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  45. My husband has long been the piano player responsible to know just when to slip quietly up to the piano and begin playing what he calls "crack music" (I have tried for years to get him to call it something else). He says he calls it this because he is playing between the cracks.
    For years he also played this music during VERY long Sunday night prayer meetings!
    He almost caused a church split when he was asked to play background music for the communion service! Oh My... I guess the communion elements are to be passed out in ABSOLUTE quiet! :)

    ReplyDelete
  46. "I guess for me background music is about honoring God with His favorite major triads, not thinking about your next witty post.

    Now where's my medal?"

    OH, SNAP!!!

    ReplyDelete
  47. "Suddenly the dulcitone notes of an "everyone listen up" song would float out of your pants." - HAHAHAHA! can this please happen sometime? that is so hilarious. if i ever get to hear you speak somewhere - this better happen. i mean i really think you should consider it!
    also, playing the emo song while being broken up with - that would definitely be cool. just think of how that would freak out the person breaking up with you - then they would be like "wow. i'm really glad i'm ending this!" haha

    ReplyDelete
  48. Actually, Jon, there is a shirt that lets you play sounds to accompany your life. It comes with a remote to hide in your pocket. Really. http://www.thinkgeek.com/tshirts-apparel/a5bf/

    ReplyDelete