When I first mentioned that I was going to do a lady version of the Metrosexual worship leader post, I got a lot of emails from confused people. Most of them said, "If metro means becoming more hip and effeminate for a guy, then a metro woman has to be a lady that becomes more manly. I'm thinking beef jerky and camo."
Those emails made sense, because in a way, I didn't do a very good job explaining the lady version post I was thinking about. And the more I spent some time with the idea, the more I realized that lady worship leaders deserve much more than just a "female version" of a post about guys. So I created something a little different.
Below is a simple quiz that will help you determine which type of lady worship leader you are or which type leads at your church. Like a scientist, I propose that there are five primary categories of lady worship leaders: The Contempohip, the Old Schooler, the Televangelist, the Crunchy and the Cure.
The Contempohip is the modern, Hillsong, kind of worship leader. North Point Community Church is very contempohip. The Old Schooler is your stuck in the 60s fundamental, old fashioned worship leader. The Televangelist has huge hair and loves to cry on camera. The Crunchy is kind of a reformed hippy with a huge heart for God. The Cure is your darker mood, paler skin kind of worship leader named after the 80s band.
They each have unique attributes, so what I did was find 20 common categories of information and then wrote out the average response each of the five types would have. Go through the quiz, total the letters you get and then use the handy score sheet at the bottom to figure out which of the five you have experience with. OK, go.
1. When it's time to make a "worship face" your worship leader does the following:
A. Contempohip = Eyes open, angry rocker girl face. Kind of Joan Jett meets Proverbs 31.
B. Old Schooler = Eyes open, big smile, waves to the crowd as if she's at a bake sale.
C. Televangelist = Cries big, black, wet mascara tears.
D. Crunchy = Eyes closed, claps hands in a weird, kind of hippy rhythm learned at a Widespread Panic concert.
E. The Cure = Face flat, semi-emotionless, decries the existence of the "worship face."
F. None of the above
2. When it comes to makeup your worship leader believes:
A. Contempohip = Wears cool stuff like Mac as if her name was Goldilocks. (Not too much, not too little, just right.)
B. Old Schooler = Makeup? You mean the devil's art form? Wears none.
C. Televangelist = Three inch base, one inch mascara, eye brows drawn on with pencil.
D. Crunchy = Believes God made her just fine. Never wears any.
E. The Cure = White base, black lipstick.
F. None of the above
3. Heaven will be:
A. Contempohip = Like one big Hillsong concert.
B. Old Schooler = Like one big Billy Graham convention.
C. Televangelist = So beautiful, sweet baby Jesus, mama is coming home.
D. Crunchy = Like a really good round of hackey sack.
E. The Cure = Like Morrissey and the Smiths got back together.
F. None of the above
4. A perfect hair day:
A. Contempohip = It looks slightly cooler than the metrosexual guitar player's hair.
B. Old Schooler = Is there anything more perfect than a nice hair bun?
C. Televangelist = Aqua net. Big. Possibly with some pink or purple highlights.
D. Crunchy = Natural. Possibly dreaded.
E. The Cure = Dark and foreboding.
F. None of the above
5. Shoes:
A. Contempohip = I got these at H&M.
B. Old Schooler = Brown high heels, not too high, more than an inch is the devil's height.
C. Televangelist = Sparkly high heels.
D. Crunchy = Bare feet
E. The Cure = Black boots
F. None of the above
6. The number of times they might cry during a service:
A. Contempohip = Not going to.
B. Old Schooler = Once, if they sing the right hymn.
C. Televangelist = Take the number of songs they do and multiply it by four.
D. Crunchy = Once, but only because she spilled her lemon wheat grass tofu granola coffee.
E. The Cure = Once, but only if someone reads an Edgar Allen Poe poem, which seems highly unlikely.
F. None of the above
7. The car they drive is a:
A. Contempohip = Audi or VW or a Mini Cooper.
B. Old Schooler = Lincoln Town Car
C. Televangelist = A Cadillac or Hummer that God told you He wanted you to have.
D. Crunchy = 87' Volvo station wagon but only when distance is too far to walk.
E. The Cure = Yellow Ford Focus, but in an ironic way.
F. None of the above
8. The instrument they play is a:
A. Contempohip = None
B. Old Schooler = Organ
C. Televangelist = Tambourine with ribbons attached
D. Crunchy = Acoustic Guitar
E. The Cure = Sad piano
F. None of the above
9. Their opinion of sequins is:
A. Contempohip = Ugh
B. Old Schooler = A little too shiny, may be from the devil.
C. Televangelist = Too much is never enough.
D. Crunchy = If that's your thing, then alright alright, it's not mine.
E. The Cure = So fake
F. None of the above
10. When it comes to holding the microphone they:
A. Contempohip = No hand held mic. Super secret almost invisible ear piece.
B. Old Schooler = Huge old-fashioned mic with big blue foam top.
C. Televangelist = Visible ear piece that she touches with her hand when she hits the high notes
D. Crunchy = Prefer to sing without one.
E. The Cure = Attached to the mic stand, refuses to hold.
F. None of the above
11. Their significant other, if they have one, is:
A. Contempohip = Named "Edge" and always stealing her hair product.
B. Old Schooler = A little uncomfortable with the idea of women being on stage at church.
C. Televangelist = Making a lot of money
D. Crunchy = Able to make his own clothing
E. The Cure = That's none of your business
F. None of the above
12. Last movie they saw:
A. Contempohip = Little Miss Sunshine
B. Old Schooler = Facing the Giants. (The edited version without all that football violence)
C. Televangelist = The Jesus Movie some missionaries sometimes show
D. Crunchy = Documentary about the earth
E. The Cure = Swedish art film, you've never heard of it
F. None of the above
13. Jewelry situation:
A. Contempohip = Very modern, deep silver pieces, possibly David Yurman or other fresh designer
B. Old Schooler = Charm bracelet, huge brooch on jacket
C. Televangelist = If God didn't want us wearing diamonds, he wouldn't have made em' so shiny!
D. Crunchy = Hemp necklace
E. The Cure = Black rubber bracelets
F. None of the above
14. Clothes they wear:
A. Contempohip = Designer jeans. Lucky or seven or paper denim
B. Old Schooler = Floral dress
C. Televangelist = Something in purple, possibly a pants suit
D. Crunchy = Homemade dress
E. The Cure = Black jeans, black hooded sweatshirt, black t-shirt
F. None of the above
15. Teeth:
A. Contempohip = Brightened with Crest White Strips, may have had adult braces.
B. Old Schooler = Dentures
C. Televangelist = Huge, billboard-sized veneers
D. Crunchy = Normal
E. The Cure = Refuses to smile, can't verify if she even has teeth.
F. None of the above
16. Dance style:
A. Contempohip = Side to side move
B. Old Schooler = Dancing is, you guessed it, of the devil.
C. Televangelist = Kind of like a Christian version of the Electric Slide
D. Crunchy = Akin to what you might see at a Phish concert
E. The Cure = You have to be kidding me.
F. None of the above
17. Prayer style
A. Contempohip = Short, sweet, well said
B. Old Schooler = Prone to "putting the devil on notice"
C. Televangelist = Long, very long
D. Crunchy = So tempted to throw a "mother earth" in there
E. The Cure = Quiet, but eloquent
F. None of the above
18. Tattoo
A. Contempohip = Normally does not have one, but may have a small, unseen tribal design
B. Old Schooler = Tattoo? Get behind me satan!
C. Televangelist = Oh heavens no.
D. Crunchy = A dolphin jumping a sunset on the back of a butterfly
E. The Cure = What vanity
F. None of the above
19. Favorite store
A. Contempohip = IKEA
B. Old Schooler = Sears Roebuck Catalog
C. Televangelist = Macy's or Barney's
D. Crunchy = We try to live off the land instead of shop
E. The Cure = Hot Topics, but only to laugh at how dumb it is
F. None of the above
20. Arch nemesis
A. Contempohip = Old church members that think she sings "too loud"
B. Old Schooler = These kids today with their hip hop and their interweb sites like "FaceSpace"
C. Televangelist = The IRS
D. Crunchy = No one. One love.
E. The Cure = Fake happy people.
F. None of the above
In order to get a score, add up all the letters and check out the info below:
"A" Answers Mostly = Contempohip
You are modern. You are singing at the Catalyst Conference and wearing hip clothes. Your jeans cost as much as some people's car payments. You go to the gym but only to take a hip hop dance aerobics class. You like Hillsong and think that Rob Bell is cool.
"B" Answers Mostly = Old Schooler
"Why do we need lasers in church? Can someone tell me that? And what's with all the Chris Tomlin?" You like to sing songs that are at least a century old. You petitioned the elders to get the youth minister to shave off his goatee. You might be a grandmother and think it's a little bit scandalous for women to wear pants.
"C" Answers Mostly = Televangelist
To you, makeup is like manna from heaven. Your eye shadow might be purple. You don't know what all the fuss is about God giving you a mansion here on earth. Even at home you call your husband "Pastor." Your dog is small and white and able to fit in a designer purse. You call everyone "honey child."
"D" Answers Mostly = Crunchy
Before you found God, you found Jerry. As in Jerry Garcia and the Grateful Dead. You call shoes "prisons for feet" and can throw the Frisbee better than any of these other stereotypes. You are completely comfortable with living in a van for a few months on an extended road trip. You may be Vegan, but are cool with people that eat meat. You don't push your views on others. Your Bible cover made of hemp bothers the Old Schooler.
"E" Answers Mostly = The Cure
You are kind of goth, but that word doesn't do you justice. You get a bad rap for being dark and depressed, but the truth is you're pretty happy on the inside. You hate the commercial side of Christianity and sing because you have to, like a bird given wings has to fly. You stand out at church but you did in high school too and you were able to get over that.
"F" Answers Mostly = None of the above
I think most lady worship leaders will fall in this category. You keep switching things up. You're like Madonna, always changing your style. You remind me of what Patrick Swayze said, "she's like the wind." We can't label you. We can't put you in a little box. You don't fit one style but rather take the one that makes the most sense in any given situation. We love you.
Whoa, that was one long parade of stereotypes. Chances are, your worship leader might defy those classifications, but I promise that somewhere along your church journey you have experienced one of those.
Which type did I miss?
p.s. Folks often ask if they can link to this site. By all means, that is awesome. Feel free if that's what you want to do.
Monday, June 9, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

49 comments:
ohh dear lord! that crunchy tattoo of a dolphin over a sunset on teh back of a butterfly made my day!
just curious, where do the flag wavers fit in?? :)
Having The Cure as a worship leader would be great...definitely not like any of the worship leaders at my church. One time I was working the soundboard and saw a CD that said "The Cure" in big letters on it near the CD player. My first reaction was, "Wow, my church has suddenly become awesome." My second reaction was to notice that it said "original soundtrack" below that and had a picture of a smiling child on it. I was disappointed, needless to say.
I think the category which most women worship leaders I've met fall into is a cross between the old school and contemporary. You know the ones who are older women but want to be 'hip' and keep up with the trends of today? They sometimes have a tamborine but most of the time just sing, and let's be honest, most of them can't really sing. They just hit those really high notes and close their eyes and wave their hands a lot.
Okay, I took this highly anticipated quiz and I had slightly more "contempohip" points (by my own rating) than "F - none of the above". I did score a "Crunchy" point for having natural teeth, and a "Cure" point for wearing black boots alot, but I was completely unable to identify my dance move style so I sent this out to my team. They can help! (i like sparkly heels, but don't wear them, and I would love to go barefoot but don't,I want a tattoo and my husband is repulsed by the idea - does that say something about my worship leading style?)
Maybe I am just an original.....
I think this is one of your best!!
OMG!! That is too funny. I am more crunchy then anything, but kinda Contempo. Our main worship leader is completely Contempo but I love her.
This is fabulous. I scored a mixture of crunchy, contemptohip, and "none of the above." Which I kind of expected.
But I think you did miss one type of female worship leader. I am referring to the one who beams at the congregation throughout the entire set, when she's speaking about God, sounds like she's on uppers, and is usually in her mid-30's to mid-40's. She sings a mix of songs, but sings each one with the same rapturous gusto, as if it is newly discovered. The church I regularly attend when I'm at school has several of these (as well as a random harmonica soloist). These women feel vaguely reminiscent of most color guard girls I knew in high school (as long as we're going for stereotypes).
Though I imagine that would fall under "none of the above", so in all actuality, no you didn't miss a thing.
As a worship leader, I think I have equal representation with crunchy, contempohip, and none of the above. I'm not the Cure, and I'm even less old school.
Meghan
Very funny! My worship leader would be under "none of the above." The thing that scares me is how much I identified with The Cure. I'm not a worship leader, but I think that's what I would be if I was one. (No black lipstick though.)
My husband used to be the youth pastor at a REALLY conventional Southern Baptist church. He was once accosted for using the NASB (they were strict 1611s). I suspect that if he had grown the seemingly-obligatory YP goatee, they would have ousted him. The ladies who sang there were a pretty even mix of Old Schoolers and Televangelists (oh, those bangs). Now we go to a different church, and most of the girls who sing there are ContempoCrunch. One couple just moved to Nashville (AKA: the Christian Hollywood - post forthcoming?), so I may actually sign up to sing on Sunday nights. Finally, a group of worship ladies who don't intimidate me with their flaming blush and frizzy perms!
PS: Our lead WP is a man who scored in the Goatee Guy range. Last night, he definitely busted out a recorder/pan flute-type instrument. Does this add to his points or detract from them? Based on the size of his biceps and the cut of his jeans, I'm thinking he has the potential to make the pan flute rock and roll. Your thoughts?
Very funny! Hadn't realized just how crunchy my church was before. But "bible cover made of hip"? Is that a typo?
Great post, as usual. I particularly like how "vegan" got a capital letter.
w00t!
Televangelist = The IRS
LOL!
You know, as far as the "dance style" goes you have to include the "praise team march". Most women on praise team start out tapping one foot. Then, they upgrade from just one foot tapping to both feet tapping... two on the right then a few on the left. Eventually (especially if the song is really moving) they start marching. It's not knee to chest marching, more of a subtle "she doesn't realize what she's doing with her feet" kind of thing. I'd say the F-none of the above girls fall into the Praise Team March a little easier than the others.
I'm guilty of it, I'll admit it. But mark my words, it's a phenomenon that has swept the nation!
Way too funny! Love it!
I just found both of your blogs and am bookmarking them! You are funny, but better than being funny, you are so honest and transparent. This is how all Christians should be. Anway, I read several of your posts, and thoroughly enjoyed them : )
And yes, through the years I have seen all of these lady worship leaders in one form or another ! LOL
loved this post! i don't have a musical note in my body, but i'm learning to play the guitar, and if i ever join a worship team at a church, i'd be equal parts contempo/crunchy/none of the above, and a lil cure. again, very cool post, i was laughing at my computer screen the whole way through!
Dear Lord... I have a Crunchy Old School Cure at my church. I think that sounds like some sort of distorted cereal for goth grandmas.
And a Dirty Dancing quote? Really? Watch out- the old schooler's are comin' to getcha!
(from Luke)
Yeah! I am an "F" and as Sally Field would say "You like me! You really like me!" :)
This is so stinkin true!! You are so great at putting ideas to words. I think that there is one more stereotype though.... the wanna be white gospel singer who has to pull a mariah carey on every song! ok, gotta go check my facespace!
No, no, no. True Old Schoolers play the accordian! The last vestige of the original female worship leader.
Old School worship leader = the Junior High choir parady on SNL...the one with Wil Ferell and Sherri O'Terry. Every song is an anthem. Both of them are so outdated it's ridiculous. Rockin' the keyboard and the warbel.... (operatic) "I like big butts and I cannot lie..."
And I, for one, took offense at the televangelist references. Don't you know those people are God's annointed? You're gonna get it Jon. One of these days you're gonna wish you blogged less and sent in more love offerings. I'm just saying, the pink hair lady has pull when it comes to prosperity and oozing sores.
My mom is half Old School, half Televangelist. Except that she wears sweatpants to church on Sunday nights and rarely wears shoes when she plays the piano.
And she likes my mohawk and tattos.
The Old-Schooler sounds an awful lot like the Church Lady. I'm picturing Dana Carvey in drag.
do Old School and female worship leader even fit in the same context????
I'm a band member who gets to talk once in a while, so I took the test......Crunchy, with touches of Contempohip! Yay! :oD
Except for the tambourine, no ribbons. Hey, gotta have something to do when I'm not singing, right? Excellent stuff, Jon!
Does a Contempohip worshipleader get bonus points in the Clothes they wear category if they've used something that happened to them while shopping for jeans as a sermon illustration when they've preached?
Amazing. Absolutely amazing. I laughed the whole way through! However, I did score as a blend of "none of the above" and "contempohip" with a dash of "crunchy" mixed in. You hit the nail on the head with this one.
I think I am a a slightly contempohip oldschooler. Yes, I'm considering therapy.
I couldn't pick Chris Tomlin out of a line-up, I've never heard of this Catalyst shindig, and I firmly believe that if the fence needs painting that I ought to paint it. I haven't seen a movie since I started watching 24 (can you work in the phrase "I'm gonna need a hacksaw"?), and baby, I got all my own teeth.
Now, stand with me, grab that fabu-smelling hymnal, and let's all sing a real fine "Man-hymn" like "There is a Fountain Filled With Blood"!
Hey, lay off the charm bracelets! I'm waiting for my fifth child's head charm to come back from James Avery as I type.
:)
David Yurman does not equal fresh....sorry that my first comment on here is negative because I love your blog! But, I know my jewelry!
I got A most, with 8 answers...with D & E coming in a far second, both with 4 answers. Luckily I got 0 for televangelist. Hallelujah, praise Jesus, thank the Lord God Almighty Savior of the world...
And, it's Hot Topic, not Hot Topics. Silly, silly. Why wouldn't that store want more than one hot topic? I guess they really are lame.
Does it weird anyone else besides me (the lady worship leader) that I am splite STRAIGHT DOWN THE MIDDLE between the contempop and the hippie?
At first I thought...I can't be type cast into a worship leader style...and then I began to realise...I'm a weird contempohip/crunchy hybrid!!!
Off to get some prayer....
This is hilarious on so many different levels that I don't even know where to begin.
"sweet baby Jesus, mama is comin home" --- best line ever! hilarious!
My worship leader ended up predominantly contempohip, very accurate!
I must say that one of the significant other choices should be "the youth pastor." In my experiences churches love to do this to get a 2 for 1 deal.
I've got to suggest a possible change to question 18... I'm imagining that The Cure has a "full sleeve" hidden underneath the black hooded sweatshirt... or at least an ironic butterfly on the left shoulder blade.
btw... I think my wife is going to love this post.
I knew my worship leader was Contempohip before I took the quiz. I will say that I think Contempohips are a little more emotional sometimes than I think this quiz gives him.
I love you Jon. I really do. This was great.
you forgot to mention how much us crunchies love working bob marley's 'redemption song' into a worship service any chance we get and secretly listen to hillsong under our covers at night.
My wife is a worship pastor and I don't steal her hair product but she steels mine!! Think that may fall into category A somewhere!
jason de stratis =
sorry re the butterfly opinion - it's a "wicked past testimony" tramp stamp on the small of her back, or no tat @ all for the cure girl. just speaking from my own life experience here.
3. Heaven will be:
C. Televangelist = So beautiful, sweet baby Jesus, mama is coming home.
It is a good thing I am alone in the office at the moment because I laughed pretty hard at this!!
Thanks Jon! I agree with the others, this is one of your best!!
C!
Stolen from a book title, and what I put for "about me" on my Facebook profile: "Birkenstocked, Countercultural, Evangelical, Hip Homeschooling Mama"....
Please, Jon, the Crunchy would have to be wearing BIRKENTSTOCKS (with ragg socks in winter)!
My lady worship leader at my church is old school with a little bit of contemporary thrown in, like a surprise bonus feature. You never know when a Hillsong song will come out of her mouth! It could be right after a rousing "I'll Fly Away" or "In the Sweet By and By". I like it.
valerie,
those are called unicorn songs. (see earlier post) and i like them too.
My female worship leader is defiantly a "Contempohip" :lol:
boy this has made my day reading your website, I am now subscribed!
I'm a cross between contemporary, crunchy, and none of the above ... pretty much equal responses for each. Very interesting. What's the category for girl worship leaders who sing, play guitar, pray short, sweet prayers, love both hymns and contemporary music, wear jeans and flip flops, and occasionally skirts or dresses (hip of course), and can rock out to both Chris Tomlin and Indelible Grace/Sovereign Grace type hymns?
Haha, I am such a "crunchy" [granola?], but I want to start calling people "honey child".
Where have you seen the Cure worship leader? This one's new to me.
What about the lady who wears only pants suits and at the end of the "worship phase" (distictly different from the "praise phase" of praise and worship), goes into a litany of "weworshipyouweworshipyou, hallelujiahallelujia, youareworthyLORDyouareworthy, hallelujiahallelujia..."
BTW have you covered the dichotomy of Praise vs Worship yet?Praise must be fast and Worship must be slow!
Post a Comment