Sunday, April 27, 2008

#183. The movie "The Passion of the Christ."

I had an easier time connecting with God in the movie, "Man on Fire" than I did in "The Passion of the Christ." That doesn't make a whole lot of sense. I mean the Mel Gibson movie made roughly 786 gazillion dollars and was loved by Christians the world over. Man on Fire is a bloody revenge film with very little God. How can I write that first sentence?

I think that the God element in Man on Fire was a strong undercurrent that caught me off guard. It surprised me and engaged me in an unexpected way. I enjoyed the Passion of the Christ. I thought it was good. But I went in expecting God and faith and Christianity. So when it appeared I was ready for it. And in communication, one of the ways to grab someone is to show instead of tell. Instead of saying, "this character is cool" in a movie, you show the audience tangible ways that exhibit how the character is cool. That way, the audience gets to write their own story instead of just digesting your story. Man on Fire showed me God's love, the Passion of the Christ told me God's love. But that still doesn't really justify thinking Man on Fire is a better picture of Christ than the Passion of the Christ. So let me explain a little, but please know I am about to ruin the end of Man on Fire.

In the film, Denzel Washington plays the role of Creasy, an alcoholic black ops military man in Mexico City serving as a bodyguard for a little girl named Pita. Pita is a blonde sprite of a seven-year-old played by the ubiquitous Dakota Fanning. Throughout the first half of the film we watch as Creasy hits rock bottom, only to find a new reason to live in Pita. Along the way, we see him spend increasing amounts of time in the Bible.

But because this at the core a revenge film, Pita is kidnapped after a piano lesson. Creasy is shot multiple times and the doctors say that without a month of rest, he will die. While Creasy is trapped in bed, Pita is executed by the kidnappers. He is devastated, his world collapsing in scenes of Pita laughing and playing. He leaves the hospital and decides to track down the killers.

In a hinge scene the young mother of Pita asks Creasy what he is going to do. His response is simple, “What I do best, I’m going to kill em. Anyone that was involved, anyone that profited from it, anyone that opens their eyes at me.” This statement serves as the doorway to a veritable house of pain and suffering. The violence is shocking in both its graphicness and its creativity.

At this point, my initial idea that I saw the love of Christ in this movie seems impossible. We do not serve a God that would torture a man with a cigarette lighter or plant a plastic explosive inside another kidnapper. Our God is not cruel. I think that’s worthy of argument though, at least from an Old Testament point of view. Would the Egyptian mothers that woke to find their first born children dead in their beds agree that God can not be cruel? Would the residents of Sodom, with flesh ripped apart by sulfur falling from the sky agree that God is not violent? I’m not saying these things were not justified. I just think that maybe we make too light of the fury and might of God.

After cutting a swath of death through Mexico City, Creasy finds the pregnant wife and brother of the villain, simply referred to as “The Voice.” The Voice asks him on the phone, “How much do you want?” Creasy responds by saying “Your brother wants to speak to you, hold on” at which point he shoots off all the fingers of the brother’s hand with a shotgun. “I’m going to take your family apart piece by piece. You understand me? Piece by piece. I don’t want your money. You understand me? I want you!” It’s numbing really, the brother tied up to a pole with a bloody stump of a hand, the pregnant wife wailing. But that’s when grace first makes an appearance. The Voice calls back and says “I will give you a life for a life. I will give you her life for your life.”

The camera spins on a confused Creasy as he struggles with the idea that Pita is alive. Suddenly the violence, the rage, the wrath of Creasy sinks out of his face. In the final scene, Creasy, Pita’s mother and the kidnapper’s brother drive to an abandoned bridge in the middle of the Mexican countryside. With a bullet ridden body and a weariness that is almost three dimensional, Creasy walks up the bridge. When the kidnappers see him waiting there, they pull a hooded Pita out of the car. They remove her dirty blindfold and with eyes not accustomed to light, she squints toward the bridge. With the sound of a child witnessing an unlocked gate in hell, she screams “Creasy” and runs to the bridge. Creasy, unable to run from all the pain, waits. She jumps into his arms, and with hands dotted with blood and scars he cradles her. This is what follows:

Creasy: “Are you alright? They didn’t hurt you?”
Pita: Shakes her head no.
Creasy: Laughing and smiling in relief, “Hi.” More laughter. “Alright your mother is waiting for you; she’s right down at the end of the bridge. OK, you go home.”
Pita: “OK. Where are you going?”
Creasy: “I’m going home too.”

Pita runs to the arms of her mother. A red laser scope lands on Creasy’s heart, which he covers with a hand that is dotted in scars. He throws up his hands and walks slowly to the kidnappers. He stumbles to his knees as they drag him into a car. Pita cries watching Creasy surrender to certain death. Creasy closes his eyes in the car and dies.

I missed it the first ten times I saw the movie. Missed that I’m Pita. I’ve lived most of my life under the stairs in a dark, dirty cage. But unlike Pita, this is the place I deserve. For although she did not ask to be kidnapped or receive this experience as a consequence of her actions, I did. If this were the story of my life, justice would have already been served. The prisoner’s life is the life I deserve. But God is like Creasy. In Isaiah 30:18 it says “he rises to show you compassion.”

The new life that Creasy finds when he meets Pita is but a glimpse at how God delights in us. And it is this love, this adoration that drives him to rescue us. But is he violent? Is there anything he wouldn’t do to rescue me and rescue you? I don’t think so. To the violence question we need only look to verses like Numbers 24:8 in which the Israelites, God’s people, are said to “devour hostile nations and break their bones in pieces.” That was describing work and battles that the Lord had blessed.

Is that any less graphic than anything that happens in “Man on Fire?” God’s love has no limits. If violence is what it would take to rescue me, I have little doubt that he would be violent. That he would remove an entire planet in a flood to save the righteous family of Noah. And even though he is blessed with the ability to open the core of the earth with his fury, it is love and ultimate surrender that shows us the true depth of his heart. In the movie, Creasy could have easily continued killing the kidnapper’s family. The brother could have been tortured, the pregnant wife and unborn child murdered. But it wasn’t about revenge, it was about rescue. And when Pita was discovered to be alive, he stopped everything. He surrendered and walked willingly into a certain death.

In his last moments, before the cross, the undeniable power of Christ is revealed one more time as he heals one of the Roman guard's ears. And yet he denies it. He surrenders. That’s how I felt about the last scene in Man on Fire. Creasy had just blown off all the fingers of the brother. He had the pregnant wife and a shotgun and a mouth full of loud, angry words. But the second he knew Pita was alive, he surrendered.

I've written about it before because the scene really shook me. It made me realize, this is the Christ I serve. Powerful, fearful, able to heal the sick and blind, capable of walking on water itself. But willing to give it all up upon realizing I am found. Willing to pay the ransom with his own life. Willing to free me from a prison I created. And whether he’s crucified on a cross or forced to walk across a bridge in Mexico, he’s willing to do it all over again for me. And for you.

p.s. I liked Passion. I thought it was a well done movie. The most powerful scene to me was when Gibson showed the boy Jesus and the man Jesus stumble to the ground. My one criticism is that it felt really full. I like movies that leave me room to climb in and Passion felt bursting at the seams so it was hard for me to engage with it in some scenes.

44 comments:

DeLong House said...

Awesome

Rob said...

I've seen "Man On Fire" and I never made the connection until reading your post today. Incredible analogy, my friend, and this kind of stuff is why I look forward to reading your stuff every day. Thanks for sharing.

Andrew said...

I love what you had to say about "Man On Fire." I'm still curious as to what you think about "Passion of the Christ," though.

Prodigal Jon said...

Andrew -
Good question. I added a p.s. to the post that summarizes my thoughts on Passion.
Jon

Anonymous said...

Not just the Passion, but any movie that is "Accepted" by the Christian community is generally loved and defended no matter what. See also Narnia and Expelled for other examples. It's fascinating the kind of marketing Christian bookstores in particular will do when such a movie hits.

Never seen Man of Fire, though now I may have to. Thanks for the review!

(a post by Luke, not the anonymous the label puts on me.)

John said...

Now I really want to see this movie.

kathy said...

Wow, I never thought I'd tear up at the synopsis of Man On Fire..but I did.

I wasn't with you at first because I tend to be of the stereotypical mindset that "No one puts the Passion of the Christ, in the corner."

But I totally get what you are saying. Wow.

Love your blog!

Viva la crockpot!

Brett said...

This is one of my favorite posts.
I own the movie but haven't watched it in at least three years.
This fresh view probably put it back on the top of my list.

Denzel thanks you.

Kristie said...

thank you. your insight rocks.

Tracy Simmons said...

I'm so glad you told us the ending because I would never watch the movie but had to know how it ended! (I'm a sissy when it comes to violence and cover my eyes up through it all, so a movie like this just wouldn't work for me!)

Your view of God willing to be violent reminded me of a post I read recently by Greg Boyd. You might find it interesting, I sure did!http://tinyurl.com/5p7jz6

sammy j said...

I used an edited version of the final part of Man on Fire in an Easter Sunday service a few years ago. Such a powerful analogy. Hollywood unwittingly retells the Gospel story so many times - they just can't come up with a better one.

Check out Dead Man Walking for our story without Christ.

And one of my other favourites: from Series 1 of Lost, Jack and Kate on the beach. "3 days ago we all died. We should all be able to start over."

Callum said...

Great post Jon.

I, like others, need to go back and watch this movie again.

I got halfway throught the post when you said that Pita dies, whic sparks Denzel's killing spree, and I thought I don't remember that, I thought she was alive....but then ahhh I see!!

Thanks Jon!

Keep up the good work!

Dez!

AJ said...

that was amazing. good analysis!

Anonymous said...

"But I went in expecting God and faith and Christianity."

Which is why I haven't seen Passion. I know how it begins and ends. I'm sure I'll see it someday though.


Wow, I saw some of Man on Fire, but not all of it. I don't think I'll see it now, because I don't feel like crying. And lifting my hands in worship AGAIN while watching something secular. Glad I'm not the only one that sees God in stuff that on the surface looks secular.

Whitney Deal said...

absolutely beautiful....i was brought to tears

this is one of my favorite movies and now I know why I like it so much

David said...

Thanks to my friend Mike for sending me to your site...usually you make me laugh (intentionally), but this was one of the best 'see Christ in the culture' posts I've ever read. Thanks.

vagabond visions said...

wow. Because of your post, I'm going to create a new category in my blogroll called "Required Reading." wow.

flyawaynet said...

I'm a long time reader (well, as long a time as can be since this blog is relatively new) but never commented before. But I couldn't let this one pass by.

This is the best blog post I have ever read. I liked it so much, that much like "Vagbond Visions" I'm not just going to blogroll you (though I was intending to do that anyway at some point), but I'm going to make a special sidebar thing to get people to this post.

Christianne said...

jon, this post really moved me. like, really moved me. REALLY. i got chills on my arms and tears in my eyes when i read the part about creasy meeting pita on the bridge, laughing with her, finding out she was really okay from the words she spoke with her very own lips.

i haven't seen the movie but have wanted to. i almost didn't finish reading the post when you said there would be spoilers. but i'm so glad i did. now i know the movie is something i really do want to see, that it's not just full of gratuitous violence, that denzel washington isn't just some evil character (which is the impression i got from the confusing trailers i saw).

anyway. i so appreciate the analogies you made her to christ's love for each one of us. thank you. wow.

hoosier reborn said...

I haven't seen Passion, possibly the only christian left in the free world who hasn't...and it came as a shock to an awesome, "seeker" buddy of mine who owns it and has watched it a hundred times.

Something doesn't add up.

Movie recommendation: "Into the Wilderness".

JustMarian said...

To anonymous Luke...
Expelled is not a Christian movie.

I have to agree on Christian marketing. I heard a rumor that Rupert Murdoch owns Zondervan and I'm guessing he makes nearly as much of of that as porn on satellite.

Jessi said...

i have to say that i might just be the only christian that did not fall in love with the passion of the christ. it seems every easter and good friday people have "passion parties". nothing says party to me like watching my savior crucified. i guess it seemed kind of fake considering i have my own mental images and thoughts on the death of Jesus. i feel like making it a movie kind of cheapened (and eased) my role in crucifying Christ.

Not to say that it hasn't helped a lot of people and brought people to Christ. It just wasn't that moving experience that it had been hyped to be. Call me a heretic, but Lord of the Rings showed me WAY more of Christ than the Passion.

Dan said...

Been a reader for a while now... LOVE your blog, and this post was awesome! Someone else mentioned Christian marketing of movies... I was disappointed at the lack of marketing for The Nativity Story compared to The Passion (I know Mel put alot of his money in it). I think the Nativity Story told the Gospel more completely than the Passion in terms of the hard choices people have to make for the Gospel.

Thanks again and keep up the good work.

Claire said...

Man on Fire has been one of my favorite movies since I first saw it, for all the reasons you wrote about.

I love when the sister at Pita's school quotes Romans 12:21 to Creasy and he finishes it and says, "I am the sheep that got lost, Madre."

Amazing! Love that movie!!!

Cody Brown said...

I'm a pastor and I've used the bridge clip from man on fire set to "now my life song sings" from Casting Crowns as a part of one of my sermons. The movie and the song make very powerful statements.

seven said...

I didn't know "Man on Fire" even existed, but I think I'm going to have to watch it. It actually sounds amazing.

candidchatter said...

Amazing writing! I am all blubbery tears now.

Denzel Washington is a Christian man.

I might have to see this movie now.

Thanks,
Heidi Reed

dean said...

jon...

i thought i was the only one... well, i know i couldnt have been THE only one, but nobody else i know that saw teh movie (and very few people that i know have seen it) made the connection. i've tried to describe it to people but havent been able to relate it coherently. amazing job... i'm linking this post (and then i'm commenting on your link love post:-)

"man on fire"s one of the best movies i've ever seen... ever

J. W. Poteet II said...

Man on fire was on last night and thanks to my sister I had just read your post yesterday. I have to agree with you. The movie that really grabbed me with a christian message that I doubt very many people saw it that way was The Matrix. Neo is a man who wakes up to the fact that the world around him isn't real. Having become aware of that, when he comes back to the fake world, he is able to work miracles. And the more in tune he becomes with the real world, the more miraculous things he can do. The physical world we live in isn't the "real" world, the spirit is. And the more in tune we become with God the more miraculous things we should be able to do. The Passion was undeniably great, but like you said, it's also all spelled out for you. Great post.

Anonymous said...

Hands down my favorite post

Lauren said...

Beautiful. I love the movie anyway, but even more now. Thanks for putting a new spin on so many things.

Anonymous said...

I know all good Christians have seen the "The Passion of the Christ". It's one of those rules like reading the "Left Behind" series or being offended by Sex and the City that is required by law.

However, I have a problem. I have had a small crush, by crush I mean almost all out lust, for Jim Caviezel since I saw him in "The Count of Monte Cristo" which has prohibitted me from seeing "The Passion of the Christ". Seriously, it is beyond wrong to be hot for Jesus.

I haven't seen "Man on Fire" but will add to my list.

O4 said...

Wow! So I'm not the only person that got that out of Man on Fire.

Christian said...

Hey Jon, love the site.

If you haven't yet seen it, you need to see "Pan's Labyrinth". That movie remains my favorite undercover (albeit unintentional) demonstration of the Christian life on film. The best analogy I can think of is that it's kind of like a weird twisted Pilgrim's Progress set in Spain. I cry tears of joy every time I get to the end. Best movie ever.

with Hope,
Christian

Anonymous said...

"A life for a life...."
That says it all. Your post brought tears to my eyes.

For those who haven't seen MAN ON FIRE, it is VERY violent...a hard R. But if you see it scheduled on non-premium TV, catch it there. They edit out the worst bits for broadcast...

mattjiggy said...

much more of a popcorn/cottoncandy action flick with not as much depth as "Man on Fire", but there's a similar analogy in "Commando" with Arnold Schwarzenegger. Worth a Netflix rental.

Aliens Web Master said...

great job.

regards
Aegan ajitho

Francois said...

Jon, I am a huge fan of your writing. I found it about a month ago. I then decided to start right from the first post and have been working my way through your site, so expect arb comments like mine 6 months after the fact.

This is my favourite post so far. Booty God Booty being a close second. I so want to use exclamation points but would feel guilty....

I love the way you see the world and the way God has opened your eyes to view it in a different light to the rest of us. You are truly blessed. SCL will be part of my daily living for as long as you keep blessing us with your insight.

PeeJay said...

I hated Passion of the Christ for two reasons:
1. Where's the Ressurection?
2. Where in scripture do you find that creepy midget dude?

Gerald Malloy said...

This is a great post! I never saw that coming. Man on Fire is an awesome film.

Dave said...

Another good "accidental gospel" movie is Pitch Black. The innocent protagonist gives up her life in order to safe the life of a criminal...

MC said...

Hey Jon,

This is a wee bit of a stretch, but did you realize Denzel's character was John Creasy--J.C. I wonder if someone knew what they were doing.

Love the movie and the blog.

www.brokenvoices.wordpress.com

Jan said...

Jon, we read this post back in April and it made us go out and rent the movie. My husband and I were impacted in so many ways because of it! Of course, we live in Mexico, so it hit even closer to home, as it's a possibility that we live with - having our kids kidnapped. Just yesterday, in our little town, drug cartels called the mayor's office and threatened to go into the schools and kidnap children if the mayor doesn't remove the army troops from their patrols on our roads. The fear in the air is palpable. I awoke this morning with a sense of anxiety and stress that I have never felt. Re-reading this post has helped me immensely, though. My God is a violent God, He will go to the ends of the earth to protect me and my family. Thank you, brother, for reminding us of this - and please keep Mexico in your prayers.

Heather said...

@PeeJay

1. Where's the Ressurection?
The final scene in the movie is Christ alive in the tomb, getting ready to leave it.

2. Where in scripture do you find that creepy midget dude?
It was supposed to represent Satan, I think, but I agree, it was weird and detracted from the story, imho.